An AI is coming to cancel your memberships
Bank analysts say "inconvenience is the main moat against AI" — and AI assistants that act for people are about to make cancelling the forgotten membership effortless. If your gym, studio, salon plan or veg box relies on people not getting round to it, here's how to make the membership worth keeping instead.
Every gym owner knows the member. They joined in January, came eleven times, and haven’t been seen since March. The direct debit still goes out on the first of every month. Nobody mentions it. Not them, not you.
That quiet arrangement has paid a surprising share of the rent for a lot of small businesses: gyms and yoga studios, salon and barber plans, coffee and veg-box subscriptions, monthly cleaning, tutoring bundles, kids’ clubs.
This week, two big banks put a name to what is about to happen to it.
“Inconvenience is the main moat”
In an analysis covered by the business press today, analysts at a large US bank looked at companies that live on subscriptions and wrote one line worth pinning above the till:
“Inconvenience is the main moat against AI.”
Their point was simple. For a subscriber who gets nothing out of what they pay for, the only thing standing between them and cancelling is the bother of finding the subscription and working out how to stop it. And that, the analysts wrote, is “an AI Agent task.”
The investment chief of a big Swiss bank’s wealth arm made the wider argument: “Since its inception, the internet has been built for human eyeballs.” Every website, in that view, assumes a person is sitting behind the screen. AI assistants that act on someone’s behalf (searching, comparing, booking, cancelling) break that assumption.
The same coverage gave a sense of how fast those assistants are arriving. One personal-assistant app was estimated to have passed about 10 million US downloads in its first 40 days. With another, 40% of users had linked a payment card by their third week.
Experts quoted in the piece estimate that somewhere between 10% and 40% of people paying for a subscription don’t actually use it.
To be fair, it hasn’t happened yet
The analysts were careful: they haven’t yet seen large-scale data showing AI assistants driving cancellations. One company they rated as exposed said it had seen no sign of it. Their early view was that for many people, the savings from switching don’t seem worth the effort.
But that last part is exactly what changes when the effort drops to one sentence. “Find everything I’m paying for every month and cancel what I haven’t used since the summer” is about the most obvious job anyone will ever give an assistant. The person doesn’t have to remember your name, find your website, or make an awkward phone call. They just have to say it once.
Why this lands on small businesses
The big subscription companies the banks were writing about will survive a bad quarter. A studio with 120 members, a dozen of whom haven’t been in since spring, feels it the month those twelve go at once.
There is a well-known study of this, published in 2006, that followed 7,752 members of three US health clubs. People on monthly contracts paid more than $17 per expected visit, when a ten-visit pass would have cost them $10 a visit. On average, members waited 2.31 months after their last workout before cancelling.
Two months of payments for nothing, per member, has been part of the business model for a long time, whether anyone planned it that way or not. An assistant that checks a bank statement doesn’t wait two months.
The law is heading the same way
Assistants aren’t the only pressure. Regulators have been going after hard-to-cancel subscriptions for years:
- In the US, the federal “click-to-cancel” rule was struck down by an appeals court in July 2025 on procedural grounds. In March 2026 the Federal Trade Commission reopened the rulemaking. Commentators expect clear disclosure, consent and an easy way to cancel to stay at the centre of it. The agency has even asked whether pushing discount offers on people trying to leave is fair.
- In the UK, new rules for subscription contracts are currently due to start in January 2027, covering clear information up front, renewal reminders and easier ways out.
Neither is a reason to panic, and nothing here is legal advice. But both point in the same direction as the technology: cancelling is going to get easy, one way or another. The only real choice is whether people still want to stay when it does.
The fair question
devkoi doesn’t run memberships or take payments. It won’t manage your direct debits, send renewal reminders or stop anyone cancelling, and it can’t tell you who your sleeping members are. Your booking or payment system knows that.
It isn’t a lawyer, either. If you’re unsure what your contracts allow, ask a solicitor or attorney.
What devkoi does is the page people read before they join, and the page they look for when they’re deciding whether to stay: what the membership costs, what it includes, how to pause it and how to leave. Written plainly, so a person and the assistant reading the page on their behalf both get the same honest answer.
What to do this week
1. Count your sleeping members. Open your booking or payment system and find everyone who has paid for the last two months but not turned up. That number is the part of your income that depends on inconvenience. It’s better to know it now than to find out all at once.
2. Talk to them before an assistant does. A short, friendly message — “we’ve missed you; want to pause, switch to a class pass, or come back with a free session?” — keeps more people than any small print. Some will leave anyway. They were going to.
3. Put your memberships on your website, in plain words. Price, what’s included, any minimum term, the notice period. As ordinary text, not inside a picture of a price list, so assistants can read it too.
“Add a Memberships page. Monthly is £35 for as many classes as you like, no minimum term, one month’s notice to cancel. The ten-class pass is £60 and lasts three months.”
4. Say how to cancel. Make it easy. Mean it. It sounds backwards, but an easy exit makes people more willing to join, and it’s where the law is heading anyway.
“On the Memberships page, add: ‘To cancel, reply to any email from us or call 0123 456 7890. One message is enough. No forms, no fees.’”
5. Offer the in-between options out loud. A pause for holidays or injuries, a cheaper off-peak plan, or a pay-as-you-go pass. The person who would have cancelled outright often takes one of these if they can see it on the page. Offer it; don’t make it a hoop they have to jump through to leave.
“Add a line: ‘Away for a while? You can pause your membership for up to two months, free.’”
6. Write down what members actually get that a price comparison can’t see. An assistant can compare prices without breaking a sweat. It can’t feel that the 7am class is small enough that the instructor knows your name, or that the barber keeps your slot every other Friday. If that’s why people stay, say so, specifically and truthfully.
“Under the prices, add: ‘Classes are capped at 12, so the instructor can help you properly. Members can book a week ahead, everyone else three days.’”
7. Preview it, read it as a member would, then publish. Every change in devkoi comes with a preview link, and every version of your site is kept. When you change a price or a plan later, the update is one message away.
For years, some of the steadiest money a small business earned came from people who meant to cancel and never got round to it. That’s ending. The memberships that last will be the ones people would choose again if somebody asked them, because very soon, somebody will.