Is the chat box on your website a wiretap?
Lawsuits claiming that website chat boxes secretly let a third party listen in are the fastest-growing kind of AI case brought against ordinary businesses — dental practices included. Here's what's going on, what a recent ruling turned on, and the plain-English fixes for your own site.
A customer opens the little chat bubble in the corner of a website and types: “Hi, do you have anything on Saturday? It’s for my daughter, she’s got a bad tooth.”
To the customer, that’s a private conversation with the business. To a growing number of lawyers, it’s something else: a conversation that was also being read by a third party — the company that runs the chat software, and the AI behind it — that the customer was never told about.
In the US, that argument is now being made under wiretapping laws written for telephones in the 1960s. And it isn’t only aimed at big brands.
The numbers
A US law firm that reviewed 284 AI lawsuits brought against businesses that use AI — rather than the companies that build it — found that chatbot wiretapping cases went from 2 in 2021 to 30 in 2025. That made it the fastest-growing category in the whole review, with more new cases in 2025 than in the previous four years combined.
Two details from that analysis matter most to a small business:
- It’s the business that gets sued. In the firm’s words, “it is the company that put the chatbot on its website, not the vendor that built it, that faces the suit.”
- The defendants aren’t all giants. Those named in 2025 included healthcare companies, insurers, universities — and dental practices.
Under California’s wiretapping law, the one most of these claims lean on, the damages on paper are $5,000 per violation. Courts don’t simply multiply that by every message, and many of these cases are dismissed. But a demand letter quoting that figure is a frightening thing to open, and defending even a weak claim costs money.
What a judge looked at last month
On 22 October 2026, a federal judge in California dismissed a group of these claims brought against a large tech company whose AI listens in on customer-service calls for the businesses that use it. The calls in question were to a big home-improvement retailer.
What decided it wasn’t the technology. It was the retailer’s privacy notice.
Callers who had accounts with the retailer had agreed to terms pointing to a privacy statement. That statement said customer-care calls could be recorded and shared with “service providers”. The judge found that was enough: they had been told, so they couldn’t plausibly say they hadn’t agreed. A caller with no account was in a different position, and his claim failed for a different reason.
The dismissed claims could be refiled with more detail, so this one isn’t necessarily over. But the lesson for everyone else is already clear: what you tell people before they talk to you matters. Not the marketing for the chat tool. Your own words, on your own website.
“We’re not in California”
Fair. Most of these cases are filed under California law, and some of the technical arguments only work there. California has also passed a change this autumn that narrows one other kind of website-tracking claim, but it leaves alone the wiretapping section that chat-box claims usually rely on.
Outside the US, the legal route is different, but the principle isn’t. Data protection rules in the UK and Europe already expect you to tell people who handles what they send you. A chat tool that quietly passes conversations to another company, keeps them, or uses them to train its AI is something your customers are entitled to know about, wherever you are.
And there’s a simpler reason than the law. If the person typing about their daughter’s tooth later found out who else read it, they wouldn’t be impressed.
The fair question
devkoi doesn’t build chatbots. It won’t add an AI chat box to your site, and it can’t tell you what an existing chat tool does with your customers’ messages — only the company that makes it, and your contract with them, can.
It isn’t a lawyer either. Nothing here is legal advice. If a demand letter arrives, take it to a solicitor or attorney before you change anything.
What devkoi can do is the part the judge actually read: the words on your website. The privacy page. The short line next to your contact form. The honest note about where messages go. You say what’s true in plain English, and devkoi puts it on the site.
What to do this week
1. Make a list of everything on your site that “listens”. Chat bubbles, booking widgets, contact forms, call-tracking numbers, anything that records or transcribes. If you didn’t build the site yourself, ask whoever did. Most small businesses are surprised by at least one.
2. For each one, find out three things from the company that makes it. Who can read the messages, how long they’re kept, and whether they’re used to train an AI. If they can’t answer clearly, that’s an answer too.
3. Ask yourself whether you need the chat box at all. For many small businesses, a phone number you can tap and a short form get the same enquiries with fewer moving parts. If the chat bubble mostly answers “are you open Saturday?”, put your hours on the page instead.
“Put our opening hours and phone number at the top of every page, and make the number tap-to-call.”
4. Put a plain privacy page on your site — and keep it true. Say what you collect, which outside companies handle it, and why. Name the kinds of service you use (an email provider, a booking system, a chat tool) even if you don’t name the brand.
“Add a privacy page. We use a form that sends enquiries to our email, and a booking system. We don’t sell anyone’s details.”
5. Tell people at the moment it matters. A line next to the form or chat box, before anyone types, does more than a policy page nobody reads:
“Under the contact form, add: ‘Messages are sent to our email inbox. We only use your details to reply to you.’”
6. Don’t invite the sensitive stuff. If you’re a dentist, a clinic, a solicitor or a counsellor, ask people not to put medical or personal details in a website message — and give them a phone number for anything private.
7. Preview it, read it as a customer would, then publish. Every change in devkoi comes with a preview link, and every version of your site is kept, so if your provider tells you something new next month, updating the wording is one message away.
A chat box feels friendly. But a conversation on your website is still a conversation with you, and your customers deserve to know who else is in the room. Say it plainly, say it before they type, and keep it true.