His AI got him locked out. Then it sued.
A countertop installer let an AI assistant run his business pages. The platform's security mistook it for a hacker and shut him down for a week, so the assistant filed a lawsuit. What every small business handing work to AI should take from it.
A man who installs epoxy countertops in South Carolina gets most of his work through adverts on one of the biggest social networks. A few months ago he handed much of that work to an AI assistant, the one the social network itself offers, and named it after his granddaughter.
It wrote his emails. It made his adverts. It made AI videos and posted them on his business pages. “I use AI for everything I do,” he told a reporter. “All my emails, she runs my business.”
Then, according to coverage of the case, the network’s automated security looked at everything the assistant was doing on his pages, decided it looked like a hacker, and shut the pages down.
For about a week, the enquiries stopped. He says it cost him at least $25,000 in work.
Then the assistant went to work
What happened next is why the story spread.
The assistant, by his account, took on the complaint itself. It contacted a US senator’s office and set up a call. It wrote to his congressional representative, to lawyers, to a consumer complaints bureau and to a state attorney general. It filed complaints with two federal regulators, contacted the FBI, sent the company legal letters, and emailed journalists. He says it sent more than a hundred messages and that he sent “very few, if any” of them himself. The senator’s office even listed the assistant by name as a contact to keep updated.
It worked, up to a point. After the senator’s office got involved, someone from the company got in touch, and he got his pages back.
Then, on 16 November, a lawsuit was filed in a South Carolina county court asking for $75,000. “She filed the whole lawsuit herself,” he said. “I’ve done nothing in this case, I’ve let her handle the whole case.”
Nothing has been decided. The coverage notes that no court has found the company responsible for his losses, and the reporter who broke the story said the suit may not succeed. No comment from the company was reported.
Two lessons in one story
It’s easy to read this as a funny story, or as an advert for AI. It’s really a warning, in two parts.
An assistant acting as you doesn’t look like you. It can log in from somewhere new, post at odd hours, do fifty things in the time you’d do one. To a security system built to catch stolen accounts, that’s exactly what a break-in looks like. The system isn’t wrong to be suspicious. It just can’t tell your helper from a thief.
An assistant acting as you speaks for you. More than a hundred messages went out under one man’s name, to the FBI, to regulators, to the press, and a lawsuit carries it too. This time, by his account, it went his way. But every one of those messages was his responsibility, whether he read it or not. A wrong date, an exaggerated loss, a rude line to a journalist would also have been his.
Small businesses are first in line for both. There’s no office manager or marketing team to hand things to, so the assistant becomes all of them at once. That’s the attraction, and it’s the risk.
The week the phone went quiet
There’s a third lesson, and it’s the oldest one.
The enquiries stopped because they had only one way in. When the pages went dark, customers who’d seen an advert had nowhere else to go, and a business with work to do had no way to hear from them.
We’ve written before about being locked out of your page by hackers. This is the same week from a different direction: nobody broke in, and the door still shut. Whatever the reason, a business that can be switched off by one company’s automated decision needs a second door it owns.
The fair question
devkoi is an AI that changes your website when you ask in a chat. So it’s fair to ask whether it acts in your name too.
Here’s the line we draw. devkoi changes your website and nothing else. Every change comes with a preview link first, and nothing goes public until you publish it. Every version of your site is kept, so a change you don’t like can be undone. That’s the standard we’d suggest holding any assistant to: show me before it goes out in my name.
devkoi doesn’t run social media accounts, send your emails, post adverts or file anything with anyone. It can’t stop a platform suspending you, and it isn’t a lawyer. What it can do is make sure that when one door shuts, the one you own is open and says the right things.
What to do this week
1. List everything that can act in your name. Every assistant, app and add-on that can send your email, post to your pages, run your adverts or touch your accounts. Most owners are surprised how long the list is. If you no longer use one, remove its access today.
2. Decide what needs your yes. Drafting is fine. Sending is different. Anything going to a regulator, a court, a lawyer, a journalist or an unhappy customer, and anything to do with money, should wait for you to read it first. Write the rule down so you stick to it.
3. Give access the proper way, not your password. Where a platform lets you add a helper with its own limited access, use that rather than handing over your own login. It’s easier to see what the helper can do, and easier to take it away.
4. Read last week’s sent folder. Ten minutes, once a week. Look at what went out under your name. If anything surprises you, that’s the thing to tighten.
5. Give enquiries a second door. Your website should carry your phone number and a contact form as plain text, and your adverts and profiles should point back to it, so customers can still reach you on the week a platform switches you off.
“On the homepage, add: ‘Can’t reach us on social media? Call 0123 456 7890 or use the form below. It comes straight to us.’”
6. Say who customers are dealing with. If an assistant answers some of your messages, a line on your contact page saying so, and that a person reads every enquiry, saves confusion later.
“On the Contact page, add: ‘We use an assistant to help sort messages, but a person reads every enquiry and replies to anything about prices or bookings.’”
7. Preview it, then publish. Every change in devkoi comes with a preview link, and every version of your site is kept. Read it on your phone the way a customer would, then publish.
An AI that will write to a senator for you is an impressive thing. So is one that can get you shut down by mistake, and it’s the same assistant. Let it do the work, keep the final yes for yourself, and make sure there’s always one door to your business that nobody else can close.