Is the face in your ad real? It matters now.
A famous athlete is suing a startup over an AI-made ad that used his face and voice, and New York now requires a label on ads that use AI-made people. Here's what that means for the smiling faces on your website, and how to check every one this week.
This week, one of the most famous basketball players in the world went to court in New York over an advert.
The ad came from a young sports-betting research app. According to the lawsuit, it showed an AI-made figure in a locker room, wearing his nickname and his number, with his tattoos and a simulated version of his voice. It drew about a million views in a day. His lawyers sent a cease-and-desist letter, the company took the ad down from its own accounts, and copies kept circulating anyway.
The lawsuit goes further than “you used my face”. It alleges the company provoked the row on purpose for the publicity, treating the legal risk as a marketing expense. Those are allegations, and the company will get its say in court.
You are not about to make a fake advert with a sports star in it. But the same tools that made that ad will make a smiling “customer”, a friendly “team”, or a presenter for your homepage video in about a minute. And the rules around those faces changed this year.
Two kinds of face, two different problems
Every face on your website or in your ads is one of two things. The rules for each are different.
A real person
That means your staff, your customers, the person who used to work for you, or someone who just looks and sounds a lot like somebody famous.
Using a real person to sell something has needed their permission for a very long time. New York, for example, has required written consent before a living person’s name, portrait or picture is used for advertising since 1903. Many other places have their own version.
AI hasn’t changed that rule. It has just made it much easier to break by accident. A video of a former employee can be re-voiced. A customer’s face can be lifted from a review. A “lookalike” can be made from a description. None of it involves a camera, and none of it involves asking.
A person who doesn’t exist
That means the stock-perfect family on your homepage, the AI-generated “happy client”, the presenter who reads out your offer.
Since 9 June 2026, New York has required any business that makes an advert featuring a “synthetic performer” to conspicuously disclose it. That’s an AI-made person who doesn’t look like any real, identifiable one. It applies to visual and video ads shown to someone in New York, where the business knows an AI person is in it. The fine is $1,000 for a first violation and $5,000 after that.
There are exceptions. Audio-only ads aren’t covered, and neither is AI used only to translate a real person’s words into another language. The law doesn’t say what the label has to look like. It also doesn’t define what counts as an “advertisement”, so lawyers are still arguing over exactly where it reaches. The cautious reading is the simple one: if a page exists to sell, and the person on it was made up, say so.
It’s the first law of its kind in the US. It’s unlikely to be the last.
The bigger risk isn’t the fine
Customers have become very good at spotting AI faces. They notice the too-smooth skin, the hands, the same model on three unrelated websites. When they spot one on a small business site, they don’t think “clever”. They think: if the team isn’t real, what else isn’t?
A small business has one advantage no big brand can buy: it’s run by real people that customers can actually meet. A made-up face throws that advantage away to save the cost of taking a photo.
The fair question
devkoi isn’t a lawyer. What counts as consent, and whether a particular page counts as an advertisement where your customers live, are questions for a solicitor or attorney. This post is not legal advice.
devkoi doesn’t make your adverts or videos either. It builds your website.
What it does do is the page most people check before they trust you. When that page needs your team, your shop or your work, devkoi asks you for a real photo rather than making one up. Swapping, labelling or removing a picture later is one message.
What to do this week
1. Look at every face on your website and in your ads. For each one, write down whether it’s a real person or a made-up one. Include small ones: testimonial photos, the “meet the team” page, the people in your banner image, any video presenter.
2. Real people: make sure you have a yes, in writing. Staff, customers and anyone who has left. A short message they reply “yes” to is far better than nothing. If you can’t get one, take the photo down.
“Remove the photo of Sam from the About page. Sam has left and we didn’t ask about keeping it.”
3. Made-up people: replace them with real ones, or label them. A real photo of your actual team, shop or work is almost always the better choice. Upload it and ask for the swap.
“Replace the stock-looking people at the top of the homepage with the three photos of our team I’ve just uploaded.”
If you keep an AI-made image, say what it is, right where it appears:
“Under the illustration on the Services page, add the line: ‘Illustration created with AI.’”
4. No lookalikes, sound-alikes or borrowed nicknames. Not of a celebrity, a local personality or a competitor’s mascot, and not even as a joke. The lawsuit this week claims that a nickname and a number were enough to suggest an endorsement.
5. Put real names and faces on an About page. Only people who have agreed. One line each on who they are and what they do. It’s the most convincing thing a small business website can show, and it’s the thing an AI image can’t fake for long.
“Add an About page with our photos and one sentence each: ‘Priya runs the shop and does every fitting herself. Tom makes the deliveries and knows every street in town.’”
6. Selling to anyone in New York? Label AI people in your ads now. That includes online ads seen there, not just posters on the street. If you advertise more widely, check what applies where your customers are.
7. Preview it, then publish. Every change in devkoi comes with a preview link to check first, and every version of your site is kept. Look at the new page on your phone the way a customer would, then publish.
The ad in this week’s lawsuit took a real face without asking. The fake team on a small business homepage invents faces that were never there. Both get found out for the same reason: people trust faces. If yours is the one on your website, they’re right to.